=> [Français]
=> [Português]

Database - Alliance francophone pour l'accouchement respecté (AFAR)

Record ID : 1066
Created on : 2/12/2004
Modified on : 1/12/2007

Modify this record
Do not follow this link unless you know the admin password!

URL of this record : http://afar.info/id=1066

=> easy

Author(s) :

Gorincour G.

Year of publication :

2004

Bibliographical entry (without author) :

Letter. Making sense of rising caesarean section rates. Trials and speaking with patients take time.
The British Medical Journal 2004;329:1240.

Résumé (français) :

Reponse a l'editorial fiche 904.

Abstract (English):

EDITOR—We agree with Anderson that we should have a more comprehensive and frank debate about the ethical issues related to the role of doctors, preferences of patients, and informed consent with respect to caesarean section.1 In response to Minkoff et al,2 we argued that not offering caesarean section was incompatible with the principle of autonomy.3

Particularly in English speaking countries, the historical role of the doctor is changing, thanks to the increasing reliance on a model where the patient is seen as the consumer and the doctor as supplier of services.4 The paternalistic model is still strong in Europe, and the debate about caesarean section may simply reflect today's difficulties in building a new form of doctor-patient relationship.

Nowadays, trust is not enough for patients: they need proof and evidence. But medicine is both an art and a science, and sometimes there is no clear proof or evidence. Is trust still possible at the very time a major medical liability crisis is happening worldwide?5 Answering this question may be as long, difficult, and important as waiting for the results of any randomised controlled trial.

Sumário (português):

URL :

http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/content/full/329/7476/1240-c?etoc

Comments :

Argument (français) :

Argument (English):

Argumento (português):

Keywords :

c-section/caesarean ; deontology ; ethics

Author of this record :

C. Loup

New expert query ---  New simple query

Creating new record --- Importing records

This database is managed by Alliance francophone pour l'accouchement respecté (AFAR, http://afar.info)
affiliated with Collectif interassociatif autour de la naissance (CIANE, http://ciane.net).
It is fed by the voluntary contributions of persons interested in the sharing of scientific data.
If you agree with this project, you can support us in several ways:
(1) becoming a member of AFAR
(2) financially supporting AFAR
(3) contributing to this database if you have a minimum training in scientific documentation.